Author:

Keywords:

Social Sciences, Psychology, Mathematical, Psychology, Experimental, Psychology, Systematic review, Network meta-analysis, Psychology and educational sciences, COMPARATIVE EFFICACY, DEPRESSIVE DISORDER, INTERVENTIONS, INCONSISTENCY, ADULTS, CONSISTENCY, SCHIZOPHRENIA, ACCEPTABILITY, HETEROGENEITY, COMBINATION, Humans, Network Meta-Analysis, Sample Size, Forecasting, PDM/20/054#55758935, 0801 Artificial Intelligence and Image Processing, 1701 Psychology, 1702 Cognitive Sciences, Experimental Psychology, 4905 Statistics, 5202 Biological psychology, 5204 Cognitive and computational psychology

Abstract:

Network meta-analysis (NMA) allows the combination of evidence on the effectiveness of several interventions. NMA has mainly been applied in the medical science field, whereas in the domain of psychology and educational sciences its use is less frequent. Consequently, systematic reviews that describe the characteristics of published NMAs are limited to the field of medicine, and nothing is known about the characteristics of NMAs published in the psychology and educational sciences field. However, this information is still relevant for the design of future simulation studies and for detecting good and bad research practices. Thus, this study describes the features of the meta-analytic datasets of NMAs published in the field of psychology and educational sciences, as well as their methodological characteristics, and compares them to those observed in the medical domain. Results show that the number of studies included is larger in NMAs from psychology and educational sciences, the most commonly used effect size is the standardized mean difference (unlike the odds ratio in medicine), the sample size is smaller, more intervention groups are included, and inconsistent effects are observed more often. These results can be used in future simulation studies to generate realistic datasets. Finally, we warn about the poor quality of reporting of some technical aspects of the NMA, such as the statistical model used.