The vortex dynamics in superconducting films deposited on top of a fivefold Penrose array of magnetic dots is studied by means of transport measurements. The authors show that in the low pinning regime (demagnetized dots) a few periodic and aperiodic matching features coexist. In the strong pinning regime (magnetized dots) a richer structure of unforeseen periodic and aperiodic vortex patterns appear, giving rise to a clear enhancement of the critical current in a broader field range. Possible stable vortex configurations are determined by molecular dynamics simulations. (c) 2006 American Institute of Physics.