ITEM METADATA RECORD
Title: Closure of A Priori Knowability Under A Priori Knowable Material Implication
Authors: Heylen, Jan # ×
Issue Date: Mar-2015
Publisher: D. Reidel
Series Title: Erkenntnis: an International Journal of Analytic Philosophy vol:80 issue:2 pages:359-380
Abstract: The topic of this article is the closure of a priori knowability under a priori knowable material implication: if a material conditional is a priori knowable and if the antecedent is a priori knowable, then the consequent is a priori knowable as well. This principle is arguably correct under certain conditions, but there is at least one counterexample when completely unrestricted. To deal with this, Anderson proposes to restrict the closure principle to necessary truths and Horsten suggests to restrict it to formulas that belong to less expressive languages. In this article it is argued that Horsten's restriction strategy fails, because one can deduce that knowable ignorance entails necessary ignorance from the closure principle and some modest background assumptions, even if the expressive resources do not go beyond those needed to formulate the closure principle itself. It is also argued that it is hard to find a justification for Anderson's restricted closure principle, because one cannot deduce it even if one assumes very strong modal and epistemic background principles. In addition, there is an independently plausible alternative closure principle that avoids all the problems without the need for restriction.
ISSN: 0165-0106
Publication status: published
KU Leuven publication type: IT
Appears in Collections:Centre for Logic and Analytical Philosophy
× corresponding author
# (joint) last author

Files in This Item:
File Description Status SizeFormat
Heylen2014_Closure_OA.pdfOA Article Published 180KbAdobe PDFView/Open

 


All items in Lirias are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved.

© Web of science