Title: An Anatomy of Fundamental Indexing
Authors: De Moor, Lieven
Sercu, Piet
Vinaimont, Tom
Liu, Fang
Issue Date: 2012
Host Document: 10 th International Paris Finance Meeting pages:1-41
Conference: International Paris Finance Meeting edition:10 location:Paris date:20 December 2012
Abstract: Adherents of Fundamental Indexing (FI) suggest that it is more profitable to base portfolio weights on indirectly size-related indicators like accounting data rather than directly on market caps. In noisy markets `a la Roll (1984), it is argued, underpriced stocks overperform but are underweighted and vice versa, implying a ‘drag’ which FI claims to avoid. Mixed into the debate is the question whether mispricing is partly identifiable or not, i.e. whether a policy of actively increasing the small-cap weights and vv helps. Carhart style regressions are unable to explain the extra return, but that conclusion
is not robust across variant models, and there are substantial doubts about the constantness of factor
sensitivities. Cross-sectional regression of weight shifts show that the weight shifts are much larger than
necessary to avoid drag and that the cross-sectional patterns are also quite variable over time. In short,
not only there are style shifts, but they are also unstable.
To estimate the benefits from drag avoidance, purged of style shifts without having to rely on generalized FF regressions, our procedure is to sort stocks on size into vigintiles, and compare within each vigintile the performance of FI-weighted returns to equally-weighted (EW) returns, which should be immune to drag too without much style shift. We find that within-vigintile EW portfolios are style neutral w.r.t. market and value, and do not meaningfully outperform VW portfolios. Thus, avoiding
drag is not why FI does well: drag is empirically unimportant. Most or all of the prima facie benefits
must be from time-varying style shifts.
Publication status: published
KU Leuven publication type: IC
Appears in Collections:Research Center International Finance, Leuven
Research Centre for Finance, Accountancy & Tax, Campus Brussels (-)
Faculty of Economics and Business (FEB) - miscellaneous

Files in This Item:
File Status SizeFormat
AnAnatomy.pdf Published 702KbAdobe PDFView/Open


All items in Lirias are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved.