Title: Self, Other, Play, Display and Humanity: Development of a Five-Level Model for the Analysis of Ethical Arguments in the Athletic Enhancement Debate
Authors: Tolleneer, Jan
Schotsmans, Paul
Series Editors: Weisstub, David N.
Issue Date: 2013
Publisher: Springer
Series Title: International Library of Ethics, Law, and the New Medicine vol:52
Host Document: Athletic enhancement, human nature and ethics: threats and opportunities of doping technologies pages:21-43
Article number: 2
Abstract: We discuss the usability of the research model that we developed to categorise the ethical arguments around doping use and examine how they relate to each other. The five categories of the model are based on the question of what precisely is at issue when athletes take or reject performance-enhancing substances. Both pro-doping and anti-doping arguments are related to the (dis)respect shown by the athlete to 1) himself, 2) other athletes, 3) the fair-play essence of sport, 4) the social functions of spectator sport, and 5) the identity of humanity. The polarisation between liberals and conservatives is somewhat of a simplification, but it is useful for elucidating the discussion on, for example, health, equal opportunities, the spirit of sport, the sport star’s role model and especially human nature. The ethical challenge is discussed, historically pinpointed and explained with examples from our own research, current events and the research literature. The five-level model presents a grid for the reading of the perceptions and conceptions of the other contributors to this book. In general, it can help both the opponents of doping and the defenders of transhumanism to assess the power of their ethical arguments and to be aware of their relativity.
ISBN: 978-94-007-5100-2
VABB publication type: VABB-4
Publication status: published
KU Leuven publication type: IHb
Appears in Collections:Department of Movement Sciences - miscellaneous
Interfaculty Centre for Biomedial Ethics and Law

Files in This Item:

There are no files associated with this item.

Request a copy


All items in Lirias are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved.