Title: Ready or not? Evaluation of a kindergarten retention policy. Effects on growth in mathematics
Authors: Vandecandelaere, Machteld ×
Vanlaar, Gudrun
Goos, Mieke
De Fraine, Bieke
Van Damme, Jan #
Issue Date: Aug-2012
Conference: EARLI SIG 18 edition:3 location:Zürich date:29 - 31 August 2012
Abstract: Every year, many children make the transition from kindergarten to first grade, a period in which children develop rapidly. Children of this age differ tremendously in their readiness to learn, saddling parents and educators with the question of ‘what to do when a child seems barely ready to meet the expectations of primary education’. One option is to adopt a practice of retaining struggling children in kindergarten rather than promoting them to first grade. This policy is based on the belief that granting a child more time to mature will prevent failure and frustration in later academic life. However, opponents argue that kindergarten retention deprives children of access to meaningful intellectual challenges and disrupts children’s academic growth. This controversy is reinforced by previous research, yielding inconsistent research findings and often facing methodological shortcomings. Using multilevel propensity score stratification, we attempt to face these shortcomings and to answer the question of ‘how kindergarten repeaters develop throughout primary education with regard to mathematics achievement in comparison to equally at –risk but promoted (1) younger grade-mates and (2) age-mates who are in a higher grade’. We control for several covariates by utilizing three-level estimated propensity scores. Preliminary results suggest that in the repeated year, repeaters perform better compared to equally at-risk younger grade-mates who will promote to first grade. However, this academic advantage already disappears by the end of first grade, where kindergarten repeaters do not perform better in mathematics achievement compared to equally at-risk, but promoted, grade-mates.
Publication status: published
KU Leuven publication type: IMa
Appears in Collections:Educational Effectiveness and Evaluation
Faculty of Medicine - miscellaneous
× corresponding author
# (joint) last author

Files in This Item:

There are no files associated with this item.


All items in Lirias are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved.