Title: The Politics of Authenticity. Charles Taylor's Authentic Self Revisited
Authors: Moureau, Loïc *
De Tavernier, Johan * # ×
Issue Date: Dec-2011
Publisher: Peeters Publishers
Series Title: Bijdragen: Tijdschrift voor Filosofie en Theologie vol:72 issue:4 pages:432-455
Abstract: The roots of the ideal of authenticity are old and complex. From Plato till today, the human mind underwent several transformations, ending up with a Self that tends to highly estimate ‘super-values’, like autonomy and rationality. However, the critics of modernity say that those ideals are not as dominant as we might think. Given the powerful mechanisms of the free market and the evolution towards radical autonomy, resulting in radical plurality, modern society lacks political courage, true authenticity and real communication. Trying to reply, Taylor defends the modern Self and its ideals. For him, authenticity is about ‘being true to oneself’, not just about ‘knowing the truth of the Self’. To be authentic, one needs to situate oneself against a kind of horizon. Rethinking individualism in a double narrative way means, first of all, to see our lives Aristotelian-like, i.e. directing ourselves towards certain goals, making our lives worth living. Secondly, it also means regaining the courage to break through the chains of radical pluralism and to speak out for our ideals. However, Taylor’s interpretation is not unproblematic. Confronting Taylor’s beliefs with those of Michel Foucault shows both resemblances and contradictions. At first sight, Foucault and Taylor seem to offer two incommensurable stories. Foucault focuses on a third-person identity, while Taylor is presenting a first-person identity. Nevertheless, a deeper analysis shows that their frameworks are different but not opposed. Morever, the later Taylor seems obliged to adjust his position on Foucault. After discussion with Paul Patton, Allison Weir and William E. Connolly, a status quaestionis on the controversy between Taylor and Foucault on authenticity, freedom, power and truth is presented. The article ends by presenting some important nuances about Taylor’s and Foucault’s political philosophies.
ISSN: 0006-2278
Publication status: published
KU Leuven publication type: IT
Appears in Collections:Research Unit of Theological and Comparative Ethics
* (joint) first author
× corresponding author
# (joint) last author

Files in This Item:
File Description Status SizeFormat
Taylor 04.08.2011 def def.doc Published 113KbMicrosoft WordView/Open Request a copy

These files are only available to some KU Leuven Association staff members


All items in Lirias are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved.