Title: The pious sex. Catholic constructions of masculinity and femininity in Belgium (1800-1940)
Other Titles: Het vrome geslacht. Katholieke constructies van mannelijkheid en vrouwelijkheid in België (1800-1940).
Authors: Van Osselaer, Tineke
Issue Date: 29-May-2009
Abstract: The pious sex. Catholic constructions of masculinity and femininity in B elgium (c. 1800-1940) This study has a double goal. On the one hand it wants to improve the kn owledge of Catholic constructions of masculinity and femininity in Belgi um. On the other hand, by studying these gender constructions, it wants reconsider the ‘feminisation thesis’. This thesis has developed in histo rical research into a container term that covers various contents. It po ints not only at a numeric preponderance of women in the religious field , but also at content changes and at a quasi-identification of ‘feminini ty’ and ‘religiosity’. The nineteenth-century ‘feminisation’ of Christia nity has been studied and documented in various European countries and d enominations, but in the research on Belgian Catholicism it has not yet been a major theme. Still, Belgian society offers an interesting case as the Catholic realm covered a wide range of activities. As such, women a nd men could confirm their Catholic identity in both public and more pri vate fields. This study therefore focuses on the Belgian case, and more specific on the way in which gender differentiation was created and expr essed. Focus is put on the Catholic adult laity and his or her (ideal) i mage in the Sacred Heart devotion, Catholic Action and sermons. These pe rspectives offer the opportunity to point at the diversity and the flexi bility of these gender constructions. The construction of the Catholic m an in the discourse of the Apostolat de la Prière (a devotional movement dedicated to the Sacred Heart) for instance illustrates how ‘masculinit y’ and ‘emotionality’ were not necessarily considered mutually exclusive . This nineteenth-century emotionally expressive masculinity therefore m akes it hard to define the nineteenth-century Sacred Heart devotion as ‘ feminised’ on the ground of her ‘emotionality’ and ‘sentimentality’, as has been suggested in other studies. Terms such as ‘feminisation’ and th e parallel ‘masculinisation’ not only come close to an essentialist visi on, they also seem to point at a kind of permanent construction of ‘masc ulinity’ and ‘femininity’ whereas in current gender research stress is p ut on the historical, social and geographical flexibility of gender cons tructions. Furthermore the stereotype of the ‘pious sex’ appears to be o lder than the nineteenth century and it was not always used in a positiv e way in Catholic sources of the nineteenth- and twentieth century. The Catholic clergy noted the preponderance of women in religious practices also in the seventeenth century. The clergy’s observation of men’s small er interest in the religious field crystallised into a narrative of loss by the end of the nineteenth century; it incited men-oriented initiativ es and (re)definitions of religion as ‘masculine’. Similar initiatives h ave been described in other research as ‘masculinisation’, but as indica ted this term is confusing. In order to be able to grasp in historical r esearch this special attention for men’s involvement, this study suggest s stepping away from the somewhat confining terms ‘feminisation’ and ‘masculinisation’ and put the emphasis on differentiation instead, the crea tion of the difference. This offers the opportunity to describe the incr easing attention for gender difference as can be remarked in the evoluti on of the mixed Apostolat de la Prière movement into the gender-exclusiv e Leagues of the Sacred Heart. Moreover, ‘men’ do not necessarily have t o oppose ‘women’: ‘Catholic men’ can be compared to other men, e.g. ‘soc ialist men’. By shifting the attention towards differentiation, other ca tegories such as class can receive ample attention and e.g. the evolutio n of the – originally workers-oriented – Leagues of the Sacred Heart can be better defined.
Publication status: published
KU Leuven publication type: TH
Appears in Collections:Modernity & Society 1800-2000, Leuven

Files in This Item:
File Description Status SizeFormat
Dissertation Tine Van Osselaer 8 apr 09.pdf Published 7398KbAdobe PDFView/Open Request a copy

These files are only available to some KU Leuven Association staff members


All items in Lirias are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved.