Download PDF (external access)

Journal of experimental psychology. Learning, memory, and cognition

Publication date: 1989-03-01
Volume: 15 Pages: 352 -
Publisher: American Psychological Association

Author:

Schmidt, RA
Young, DE ; Swinnen, Stephan ; Shapiro, DC

Keywords:

Adult, Attention, Discrimination Learning, Female, Humans, Knowledge of Results (Psychology), Male, Memory, Psychomotor Performance, Reaction Time, Retention (Psychology), Social Sciences, Psychology, Psychology, Experimental, Knowledge of Results, Psychological, Retention, Psychology, 1701 Psychology, 1702 Cognitive Sciences, Experimental Psychology, 5204 Cognitive and computational psychology

Abstract:

Summary knowledge of results (KR) involves the presentation KR for each of a set of trials (e.g., 10) only after the last trial in the set has been completed. Earlier, Lavery (1962) showed that, relative to providing KR after each trial, a 20-trial summary KR was detrimental to performance in a practice phase with KR present but was beneficial for a no-KR retention test. Using a relatively simple ballistic-timing task, we examined summary lengths of 1 (essentially KR after every trial), 5, 10, and 15 trials, searching for an inverted-U relationship between summary length and retention performance as predicated by a guidance hypothesis for KR. During acquisition when KR was present and being manipulated, all groups showed improvements in performance across practice, while increased summary lengths generally depressed performance. However, in a delayed no-KR retention test, there was an inverse relation between the summary length in acquisition and absolute constant error on the retention test. A guidance hypothesis is favored to explain how, relative to immediate KR, long KR summaries can provide detrimental effects in acquisition while enhancing retention performance.